Saturday, February 11, 2012 4:35am EST
Make this your Home Page | RSS 
Black minister's billboard: "gay rights are not civil rights"
Rod McCullom | Posted July 24, 2009 12:41 PMThe only billboard in the Central Texas town of Gatesville (pop. approx. 15,000) has become a lightning rod of controversy. A retired black minister rented the sign on Main Street that reads, "Gay Rights are Not Civil Rights." The sign owner, Virginia Miller, tells the Dallas Voice the pastor "wanted to get the message out to black people .. everything they fought for is being hijacked."
The message was paid for by Oen Dollins of Gatesville, a former minister. Miller said Dollins didn't mean to offend anyone. "He wanted to get the message to black people that it's not fair that they're the ones who suffered, they're the ones who paid the price, and now everything they fought for is being hijacked." Miller said.
Miller also claimed she's received death threats since reports about the sign appeared on Instant Tea and on KCEN Channel 9 in Waco. She said Dollins paid $300 for the message to appear on the sign for three days, from Sunday through Tuesday, and it was taken down last night. Miller said her husband, Bo, carefully screens advertisements for "the Sign" and typically doesn't allow anything negative. But Bo Miller told Channel 9 that he approved the message because he felt Dollins was making a valid argument.
The billboard, known in Gatesville as "The Sign", first made news earlier this week when a reader emailed photos to the Voice and added: "Hate is alive and well deep in the heart of Texas." KCEN-TV interviewed some residents and one black woman said she had no problem with the sign because "as a Black woman, because I have been through ...I know what it feels like and it's totally different."
Dollins repeats this popular talking point by anti-gay black Christians: "No gays are having to ride on the back of the bus. No gays are being enslaved. No gays are being prosecuted [sic] in any way."
The Rev. Kevin E. Taylor, New Jersey-based pastor, black gay activist and author, scoffs at the "foolishness of trying to destroy the history and might of the movement." Rev. Kev adds: "Civil rights are about freedom for all. Dr. King said so masterfully: 'Until all of us are free, then none of us are free and injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere!' "
The problem is two-fold. "Gays" and "blacks" are stereotyped as mutually exclusive because black LGBTs are often reluctant to come out--read hundreds of comments here, here or here--and continue to embrace the closets of the anti-gay black churches
So saying "no gays never had to sit on the back of the bus" would be true .. only if you believe all gays are white. Just ask Bayard Rustin or any black gay or lesbian who grew up or were openly gay during Jim Crow. Better yet, if you really believe that no gays, lesbians or trans are being prosecuted (or persecuted) "in any way"' ... ask Tony Randolph Hunter, Lawrence King, Sakia Gunn, LaTeisha Green, or Michael Sandy. Or the black gay college students killed in Newark. Take a trip to Nigeria. Or Jamaica. Or Russia ...
Writer and television news producer Rod McCullom is a frequent contributor to The Advocate and The Huffington Post. His blog is Rod 2.0.
-
NEWS UPDATES
- Marja Vongerichten Talks Kimchi Chronicles (0 comments)
- ( comments)
- ( comments)
- ( comments)
- ( comments)
-
the pilates biz commented on How black voters took on the Clinton machine:
Wedding pics are always my favorite. So pretty. So happy....
-
Chykar commented on Kola Boof On Bin Laden's Death:
Well... I really don't know wat to say, she sounds like she went thru ? lot at the hands of Mr Psyc...
-
thepilatesbiz commented on The Reverse Bradley Effect:
so i think that a bit of respect for the marathon distance comes in the knowing....
-
Cecil Jones commented on Why we can't support Chris Brown:
Chris Brown has not shown the world his ability to love someone other than himself properly. We ca...
-
pletcherzam commented on Maya Angelou speaks out for Obama:
It should seem obvious that the processes that drive a cell through the cell cycle must be highly r...
Mark Allen
John Amaechi
Maya Angelou
Crystal McCrary Anthony
Patricia Arnold
Algernon Austin
Randall Bailey
Rick Blalock
Kola Boof
Keith Boykin
Mario Brossard
Michael Brown
Theresa Caldwell
Clay Cane
Jasmyne Cannick
Charisse Carney-Nunes
Audrey Chapman
Gordon Chambers
Staceyann Chin
Mark Corece
Gilda Daniels
Yvonne R. Davis
Terrance Dean
Marcia Dyson
Damon Evans
M. Franklin
Lenora Fulani
Ron Glover
Keli Goff
Peter Gomes
Deondray Gossett
Kia Gregory
Zulema Griffin
Malcolm Harris
Marc Lamont Hill
Alicia Hines
Dennis R. Holmes, M.D
Earl Ofari Hutchinson
Jessica Ingram-Bellamy
Jacqueline Jackson
Avis Jones-DeWeever
Quincy Lenear
Carl Lewis
Rae Lewis-Thornton
Shannon J. Love
Rod McCullom
Terry McMillan
M.W. Moore
Alphonso Morgan
Nicholas Nelson
Clarence Nero
Charles Ogletree
Spencer Overton
Shirley Parker
Deval Patrick
Charles Pugh
Anwar Robinson
Eugene S. Robinson
Rashad Robinson
Mark Sawyer
Tara Setmayer
Rev. William Sinkford
Alexander Smalls
Basil Smikle
Nadine Smith
Doug Spearman
John Stanley
Jamal Story
Ronald Sullivan
David Dante Troutt
Omar Tyree
Linda Villarosa
Dorian Warren
Isaiah Washington
Robin Washington
Diane Weathers
Reg Weaver
Marcia J. Williams
Nathan Hale Williams
Jeff Winbush
Kai Wright



MySpace
flickr
YouTube

2009-07-24 13:53:45
2009-07-24 14:46:16
2009-07-24 14:56:21
2009-07-24 16:01:14
2009-07-24 17:51:41
2009-07-24 19:38:36
2009-07-24 21:20:42
2009-07-24 21:34:46
2009-07-24 22:34:21
2009-07-25 01:01:13
2009-07-25 10:37:54
2009-07-25 12:52:41
2009-07-25 14:52:00
2009-07-26 01:50:43
Of course the discrimination faced by gay men and women, regardless of race, is not the same as race-based discrimination. However, the fact that it is not the same is no reason to trivialize it; it is still hurtful and damaging, to the point that it sometimes even results in suicide.
People who will not stand up for the rights of others have no right to expect others to stand up for their rights.
2009-07-26 07:08:42
2009-07-26 10:46:59
2009-07-26 11:42:57
2009-07-26 12:47:53
2009-07-26 15:48:12
I never stated that gays' struggle for civil rights is the SAME as blacks' struggle for civil rights. They are not the SAME, but there are many similarities and there is much in common. Any fair-minded person could easily see that.
I could easily enough enumerate several differences in civil rights problems between gays and blacks, but I see no point in doing so. However, I shall emphasize one important difference, i.e., the lack of support that many gay men and women face.
Black parents clearly understand the problems that their children are likely to face as the result of being black in a country where there is still significant racial prejudice. Therefore, they strive to prepare their children for the problems which they are likely to face. Often, that is not true with gays.
My parents did not prepare me for the problems which I would face as the result of being gay. Rather, when I was outed, they disowned me. Black parents do not disown their children for being black.
Blacks are generally members of social and religious organizations which help them deal with the prejudice which they are likely to face. Until recently, we gays had no such supportive organizations, and many, especially those living in small towns, still do not. Even now, sometimes parents disown their gay children, and many churches still put down people for being gay. Blacks have never had to deal with that.
As a result of negative attitudes towards themselves as the result of being gay in a hostile society, the suicide rate among young gays is extremely high. Although it is impossible to get accurate statistics, surveys have indicated that young gay persons are much more likely to be thinking about suicide than are non-gays. Although it is not uncommon for blacks to have a negative attitude towards themselves as the result of racial prejudice, that problem is much more common among gays.
I, a gay white man, was very outspoken in favor of fair and equal treatment for blacks, even before there was a significant gay rights movement. At times, I got into heated arguments over it and even lost friends as a result. Thus, I see it as quite reasonable for me to object when some blacks insist that gay persons have no rights and that by working for equal rights, we gay persons are undermining the rights of blacks.
Unfortunately, in many cases, this seems to be a matter of whose ox is being gored. I have no sympathy for those who demand their own rights while criticizing those of us who insist that our rights are also important. People who are indifferent to the rights of others have forfeited their right to expect others to support them.
2009-07-26 16:32:28
2009-07-26 18:01:03
2009-07-26 18:55:17
2009-07-26 19:51:49
Your assumption that we whites are not attempting to educate other whites about racism is invalid. Many of us have been attempting to do that for years. Obviously it is possible to be annoyed with black clergy who supported CA proposition 8 and still push for racial equality.
Vincent,
Perhaps you are unaware that the recent general convention of the Episcopal Church, which is the ruling body of the church, voted overwhelmingly in favor of full marriage equality for gay persons. It also decided that holy orders should not be denied to gay persons, i.e., that gay persons can be priests and bishops. Granted it took decades to reach that point, but we did it!! And, I must claim some of the credit. When I lived in Minneapolis, I established Integrity Twin Cities, which was the local chapter of the national organization for gay men and women in the Episcopal Church. I am still involved with Integrity.
It should also be pointed out that, unfortunately, historically speaking, constant warfare has been the normal state of the world. Warfare was the constant state before the advent of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. Thus, it is illogical to assume that warfare would end if Judaism, Christianity, and Islam ceased to exist. These religions do not CAUSE wars so much as they are the excuse for wars. If people actually followed the religions, which they commonly fail to do, wars would not exist.
Consider the history of ancient Rome. Surely you are aware that Rome, even before the advent of Christianity, engaged in warfare with several other nations. Surely that indicates that eliminating Judaism, Christianity, and Islam would be unlikely to eliminate wars.
Kevin,
I agree that blacks would be considerably more effective than whites in persuading black clergy to support equality for gay men and women. I hope that you are working to get support for equality for gays, but your views on religion would limit your ability to do so.
2009-07-26 20:06:57
2009-07-26 20:32:15
2009-07-26 20:45:08
2009-07-26 21:06:17
2009-07-26 21:14:51
No where did I state that black clergy were solely responsible for the passage or CA proposition 8. They couldn't have been solely responsible since even if they had got all their followers to support proposition 8, it obviously could not have passed without support from others since blacks are a minority in CA. Nevertheless, we do know that many black clergy have been very outspoken in their belief that somehow supporting gay rights undermines efforts to work towards ending racial discrimination. It's similar to the idea that some people have that those of us who support same-sex marriage are undermining opposite-sex marriage.
Jsean, a self-professed non-white non-gay man, seems to believe that those of us who are gay are so from choice. If I chose to be gay, then why, before I finally accepted myself, did I see a psychiatrist for 7 consecutive years in an attempt to change my sexual orientation? Why do many gay men marry women in the belief and hope that by doing so they can change their sexual orientation?
For some people, sexual orientation may be somewhat malleable. However, some people are romantically interested in both sexes, although not usually to the same degree. Their experiences confuse some people into believing that any gay person can change his / her sexual orientation.
2009-07-26 21:30:25
2009-07-26 22:06:04
2009-07-26 22:16:55
2009-07-26 23:25:58
2009-07-26 23:49:23
2009-07-27 01:08:53
It's not only black gays who attack each other. Believe me, it happens with white gays also. It can be very difficult to get gay persons to agree to do anything that would make them better off. However, at one time, it was even worse.
Way back in 1975, when I founded Integrity Twin Cities (a local chapter in the national organization for gay men and women in the Episcopal Church), I became aware that many gay men were very threatened by the idea that they might become accepted. They actually wanted rejection and although I'm sure that none would have admitted it, it was obvious from their actions. I think that it was the result of internalized homophobia and that they felt rejection was suitable and just punishment for their "sinful" condition.
You mention that black gay folks are good at attacking each other. I suspect that you are seeing what I observed many years ago when I founded Integrity Twin Cities. They may be sabotaging work that would improve the quality of their lives because they believe that they don't deserve to be accepted. Considering that clergy constantly tell them how evil they are, that shouldn't be surprising. When people believe that they are inferior and worthless, they will not stand up for their rights. It's not a problem only among gay people. At one time, because of racism, many blacks also saw themselves as inferior and, as a result, would not work to overcome racism.
2009-07-27 01:34:38
2009-07-27 10:36:11
2009-07-27 12:47:52
I suggest that instead of typing directly into the comment box, you use your word processor first. Then, re-read what you have written several times, perhaps over a period of a day or so. Then, edit and re-write until you get it right, after which you can paste it into the comment box. Often, when responses are posted too quickly and without careful thought, they do not effectively communicate what the writer meant to say.
Also, watch those run-on sentences. A good high school English teacher would completely use up his red pencil if many students wrote the way you do. In addition to making it difficult to read, long sentences which contain several thoughts convey the impression that the writer is being excessively emotional rather than thinking clearly and calmly.
I'm sure that you want people to understand your viewpoints and be influenced by them. That goal can be best accomplished by clear, careful, well-organized, and thoughtful writing.
Unfortunately, this web site does not make it clear how to insert paragraph breaks and different web sites require different methods. To insert paragraph breaks, type a left angle bracket, P, and a right angle bracket with no spaces between them.
2009-07-27 13:03:10
2009-07-27 13:48:28
2009-07-27 15:35:42
2009-07-27 17:43:23
2009-07-27 20:44:34
2009-07-27 23:16:20
2009-07-27 23:23:05
2009-07-28 01:45:17
2009-07-28 02:30:45
2009-07-28 10:38:12
2009-07-28 16:19:49
2009-07-31 16:14:36
2011-04-18 00:45:43
2011-07-15 05:37:28
2011-08-13 07:44:21
2011-09-15 13:40:19
2011-11-15 09:37:04
2011-11-16 08:53:32
2011-11-16 18:32:29
2011-11-17 06:07:11
2011-11-19 08:13:01
2011-12-19 19:48:56
2011-12-25 04:48:52
2012-01-05 17:15:20
2012-01-15 15:35:13
2012-02-08 07:35:10
To see your comment, wait approximately two minutes, then simply refresh the page.
Report issues/abuses to suggestions@thedailyvoice.com